SOURCES OF STATE SOVEREIGNTY AND THE IDEA OF NATIONAL IDENTITY


DOI: https://doi.org/10.17721/2415-881x.2020.85.158-173

Mykhailo Boichenko (Бойченко Михайло Іванович), Yuliia Rudenko (Руденко Юлія Юріївна)

Abstract


The article is devoted to the analysis of the ratio of external and internal sources of state sovereignty. It is found that sovereignty cannot be established without external sources, and the sovereignty of the state is to establish external relations with other states as political monads, i. e. coexisting political substances. At the same time, the sovereignty of the state is closely interconnected with the idea of national identity: the justification of sovereignty is the integration of all cultural groups of the country around the idea of national identity, which is the subject of protection of state sovereignty. The national idea acts as the main source of legitimation of the state’s sovereignty, and the national identity acts as a mechanism for combining the national idea and the state’s sovereignty.
In today’s globalized society, national identity appears not as an opponent of internationalism, but as a prerequisite for building international relations in recognition of the sovereignty of states that have their own national idea. The global state appears not as a replacement for the nation-state, but only as a principle of interdependence and expression of the need for cooperation between modern nation-states. Global civil society creates a need for the principle of multilateralism in the interaction between modern states, i. e. the need for their constructive interaction based on mutual respect for the idea of national identity and its derivatives — national interests, national values and so on. The strategic provision of internal sources of state sovereignty, especially a clear link between national identity and the integrated national idea, makes possible and appropriate to turn to external sources of state sovereignty.


Keywords


state sovereignty; national idea; national identity; global state; national interests

References


Anderson B. (2001) Imagined communities. Reflections on the Originand Spread of Nationalism / trans. from English by V. Morozov. 2nded. Кyiv: Krytyka, 272 с. [In Ukrainian].

Bebyk V. (2006) Global Civil Society: Theory, Methodology, Management. Political management. 2, 140–147.

Boychenko M. (2018) Legitimation and Delegitimization: The Value Basis of Social Norms. Philosophy in the modern world: Proceedingsof the All-Ukrainian scientific-practical conference, November 16–17, 2018 // Ed. Y. V. Tararoev, A. V. Kipensky, L. V. Perevalova [etc. ].Kharkiv: Tochka, 118–120. [In Ukrainian].

Vdovychyn I. (2015) The Crisis of the Sovereign Sstate and the Project of the Power Institution of the Global Community. Bulletinof Lviv University. International relations series. 37: 3, 17–27. [InUkrainian].

Hegel G. W. F. (2000) The Scientific Ways of Treating NaturalLaw, Its Place in Moral Philosophy, and Its Relation to the PositiveSciences of Law / trans. from German by R. Osadchuk, M. Kushnir.K.: Universe, 329 p. [In Ukrainian].

Hobbes T. (2000) Leviathan, or The Matter, Forme and Power of aCommonwealth Ecclesiasticall and Civil / trans. from English by R.Dimerets, V. Yermolenko, N. Ivanova, E. Miroshnychenko, T. Oliynyk.Kyiv: Duh I Litera, 600 p. [In Ukrainian].

Husserl E. (2006) Cartesian Reflections / trans. from German byD.V. Sklyudneva. Saint Petersburg: Nauka, 320p. [In Russian].

Durkheim E. (1991) Division of Labor in Society / trans. from French. Durkheim E. Division of Labor in Society. Method of Sociology.Moscow: Nauka, 5–380. [In Russian].

Kulakov A. (ed. ) (2017) Words and Wars: Ukraine Fighting KremlinPropaganda. K.: KIS, 132 p. [In Ukrainian].

Lozovy V. S. (2019) Modern humanitarian policy of Hungary:challenges for Ukraine. URL: https://niss.gov.ua/doslidzhennya/gumanitarniy-rozvitok/suchasna-gumanitarna-politika-ugorschini-vikliki-dlya-ukraini [In Ukrainian].

Luhmann N. (1991) Tautology and Paradox in the Self-descriptions of Modern Societies / trans. with him. A.F. Филиппова. SOCIO-LOGOS.1.M.: Progress, p. 194–218.

Leibniz G. W. (2013) Monadology / trans. from French by Pavlo Bartusiak edited by Oleg Khoma. Sententiae, XXVIII. 1, 151–177. [InUkrainian].

Marx K., Engels F. (2010) Manifesto of the Communist Party / trans.from German. Kyiv: Vpered, 56 p. [In Ukrainian].

Mairet J. (2003) The Principle of Sovereignty. History andFoundations of Modern Power / trans. from French by L. Kononovich.Lviv: Kalvariia, 2003, 216 p. [In Ukrainian].

UN 203015. (2016): Restoring order in a fragmented world Report ofthe Chair Independent Commission on Multilateralism (ICM) URL:https://www.ipinst.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/IPI-ICM-Chairs-Report-Russian.pdf

Marsilius of Padua (2014) The Defender of Peace / trans. from Frenchby B. U. Esenova. M.: Dashkov i K, 656 s. [In Russian].

Tishchenko Yu. A. (ed. ) (2019) Romanian and Moldovan NationalMinorities in Ukraine: Status, Trends and Opportunities for Cooperation: Coll. scientific expert materials / [Yu. A. Tishchenko, A. M. Kruglashov, V. O. Bakalchuk, S. V. Dubova, N. V. Nechaeva-Yuriychuk]. K.: NISS, 112 p. [In Ukrainian].

Semchyshyn S. I. (2014) Feminist analysis of the role of the state and sovereignty in international relations. Philosophy and political science in the context of modern culture. Issue 8. Political Science, 260–263. [In Ukrainian].

Spinoza, B. (2015) Ethics / trans. from Latin. Strelbytsky MultimediaPublishing House. Electronic edition. [In Ukrainian].

Philpott, Daniel (2020) Sovereignty. Stanford Encyclopedia ofPhilosophy. URL: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/sovereignty/

Fifty States have established the Alliance for Multilateralism (2018). Share URL: https://multilateralism.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Alliance-for-Multilateralism-Declaration-of-principles.pdf


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

The editorial board does not always share the position of the authors. The authors are responsible for the accuracy of the material presented.
All rights reserved.
© Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, 2026