THE STATE OF DEVELOPMENT OF DELIBERATIVE DEMOCRACY IN UKRAINE
DOI: https://doi.org/10.17721/2415-881x.2020.84.106-118
Abstract
The relevance of the state of deliberative democracy development in Ukraine is connected with the low efficiency of interaction between civil society and public authorities in Ukraine, as well as the inadequate level of functioning of existing deliberative democracy instruments. Since the decision-making system that was developed in recent years in Ukraine does not provide a rational approach, but is based on a one-sided understanding of political realities without taking into account the views of civil society, it is necessary to explore the deliberative democracy in Ukrain, by which the author understands the model of democracy, which is based on institutionalized dialogue between government and civil society, rational discourse, discussion, persuasion, argumentation, compromise, in which compliance ensures rational decisions.
The comparative method was used in comparing the procedural consolidation and, in particular, the actual holding of public hearings by the Ternopil City Council and the Ladyzhyn City Council. The structural-functional method allowed to study the main mechanisms of deliberative democracy (local initiatives, general meetings of citizens, public hearings) as a factor in increasing the level of citizen involvement in political decision-making.
Based on this, an absence of the mechanism to control the decision-making process on local initiatives was identified. The article proved the incapacity of deliberative instruments in Ukraine, without overcoming which it is impossible to count not only on the ideal, but also, at least, on the optimal model of development of deliberative democracy. As a result, the author presented ways to improve the legal regulation of the general meetings of citizens at the place of residence in order to increase the level of citizens involvement in the deliberative discourse in Ukraine.
Keywords
Full Text:
>PDF (Українська)
References
Baimuratov M. O. (2009). Territorial community is the basis of1.local self-government in Ukraine. Municipal law of Ukraine. M. O.Baimuratov (Ed. ). Kyiv, pp. 247–318. [in Ukrainian].
Decision of the Kyiv City Council of the III session of the VIII2.convocation On approval of the Procedure for submission andconsideration of local initiatives in the city of Kyiv from December8, 2016 № 545/1549. Retrieved from: https://kmr. gov. ua/uk/content/poryadok-vnesennya-ta-rozglyadu-miscevyh-iniciatyv [inUkrainian].
Local initiatives of the Kyiv City Council. Retrieved from: 3.https://kmr. gov. ua/uk/comisii/26/local-initiatives [in Ukrainian].
Decision of the Kyiv City Council On renaming the street in the4.Pechersk district of Kyiv from April 4, 2019 № 512/7168. Retrievedfrom: http://kmr.ligazakon.ua/SITE2/l_docki2.nsf/alldocWWW/A862DA1775EFFAE4C22583DE0036FF15?OpenDocument [inUkrainian].
Law in Ukraine on local self-government in Ukraine from May 215.1997 № 280/97–VR. (2020, April 06). Retrieved from: http://zakon3.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/280/97-%D0%B2%D1%80 [in Ukrainian].
Report on the results of the assessment of the state of implementation6.of local democracy instruments in local self-government bodies of the Vinnytsia City Territorial Community (Urban Democracy Index). (2020). Retrieved from: http://pleddg.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/CDI-Vinnytsia.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Index of urban democracy 2020. (2020). Retrieved from: 7.https://decentralization.gov.ua/uploads/library/file/631/City-Democracy-Index-2020.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Resolution of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine On Approval of the8.Regulations on the General Meeting of Citizens at the Place of Residence in Ukraine from December 17, 1993. Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/3748–12#Text [in Ukrainian].
Khmilnytsky District State Administration — official web-site.9.Retrieved from: http://rda-hm.gov.ua/novini/v-markushah-i-v-pustovijtah-hmilnickogo-rajonu-vidbulisya-zagalni-zbori-gromadyan/ [in Ukrainian].
Khmilnytsky District Council — official web-site. Retrieved from:10.http://hmrayrada.gov.ua/news/2019–03-14–04/ [in Ukrainian].
Report on the results of the assessment of the state of implementation11.of local democracy instruments in local self-government bodies of the Khmelnytsk City Territorial Community (Urban Democracy Index). (2020). Retrieved from: http://pleddg.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/CDI-Khmilnyk. pdf [in Ukrainian].
Andriychuk T. (2012). The concept of civil society in modern theories12.of democracy. Political management. Kyiv. 1/2, pp. 10–17. [in Ukrainian].
Bartaharieva I. (2013). The deliberative paradigm of civil society and13.the rationality of legal discourse. [in Ukrainian].
Ternopil City Council — official web-site. Retrieved from: 14.https://ternopilcity.gov.ua/generalniy-plan/37082.html [in Ukrainian].
Decision of the Executive Committee of the Ternopil City Council15.About the statement of the town-planning documentation «Detailed plan of the territory limited by street Zhivova, street Tantsorova, Heroes of Euromaidan Square, street Doli, street Metropolitan Sheptytsky (residential district «Zhyvova» residential area «Central») in Ternopil from April 15 2020. Retrieved from: https://ternopilcity.gov.ua/vikonavchiy-komitet/rishennya-vikonavchogo-komitetu-2019/38523.html [in Ukrainian].
Medvedska V. Y. (2019). Online deliberation as a way to increase16.public participation in political decision-making. Gilea: scientificbulletin. Kyiv. Issue: 148 (№ 9). Part. 3. Political sciences, pp. 51–55.[in Ukrainian].
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
The editorial board does not always share the position of the authors. The authors are responsible for the accuracy of the material presented.
All rights reserved.
© Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv, 2026






